approvedAdirondack Curriculum Project - www.adkcurriculum.org
NYS Content Area Standard

Health, PE, Home & Careers
2.
A Safe & Healthy Environment

Title: Equipment Selection

Grade Level: 10th Grade

Author: Jack Drury
Leading Edge

Email: jack@realworldlearning.info
Adirondack Curriculum Content Area
___ Natural History
___ Human History
___ Culture & the Arts
___ Government & Civics
___ Economy
_X_ Health, Recreation & Life Skills

Investigative Question or Issue: What criteria should we use to guide our selection/purchase of major pieces of equipment for backcountry travel?

Challenge:
 
 Context for this Challenge: You are a team of editors for Backcountry Trekker magazine. Thousands of subscribers anticipate your annual review and recommendations regarding the quality of new gear for backcountry travel. As part of your annual process, your team reviews and re-establishes its list of criteria for making recommendations in each category of equipment: backpacks, tents, sleeping bags, sleeping pads, and stoves. This year you agree to make equipment recommendations appropriate for three-season travel in the Adirondacks.

Follow this process to set up the remainder of this challenge:
1)  Form teams. Each team should examine the references provided and, based on your research, begin to create a team’s list of criteria for selecting each of the pieces of equipment cited above.
2)  Once all the teams have completed their research, organize a “Carousel” with the help of your instructor. In this Carousel, acquire five pieces of blank poster paper and title each one with the label of a different piece of equipment. For instance, one poster paper is labeled “backpacks”, another “stoves”, etc.
3)  Timed by the instructor, each team should move from one poster to another writing down its suggestions for criteria for the equipment cited at the top of the paper. Build on or add to the suggestions of previous teams. NO CROSSING OUT CRITERIA SUGGESTED BY PREVIOUS TEAM!
4)  Once all teams have commented on all equipment, have first team to comment on each poster return to that poster and distill/clarify/cull the language so the list of criteria is clear to all. Post these clarified lists for viewing, discussion, and common agreement, if possible. Each team must be prepared to support any of its suggestions with references to specific authoritative sources if challenged to defend what the team has written.

The Challenge: Using the criteria established, create an engaging and informative print ADVERTISEMENT wherein you recommend a specific piece of equipment in each category above as the BEST VALUE for your readers. Your selections must be currently available for purchase. Be prepared to share both your advertisement and the rationale behind your choices with others in the group.  

Quality Standards:  

Quality Standards:
     
Form Criteria
  • Advertisement is on one page of poster paper.
  • Advertisement is engaging – causes the viewer to look with interest, pause, and read.
  • Advertisement is informative – provides viewer with important/relevant information.
Content Criteria
  • Advertisement includes a recommendation for a BEST VALUE piece of equipment in each category.

Knowledge
  • Participants can knowledgeably discuss the criteria for selecting major pieces of backcountry equipment.
  • Participants can adequately defend their Best Value choices in terms of the established criteria.
Skill: Decision-making: Analyzes and prioritizes relevant information.
  • Participants can cite information from authoritative resources that supports their choices of criteria and equipment.
Adapted for the Adirondack Curriculum Project from the work of Education By Design TM and Leading EDGE, LLC ©ACP 2002

   Product Quality
Checklist
Date: ________                                                                     Class Period: ________
Product Author(s):

 

 Product Title/Name:
Equipment Selection
Evaluator Name(s)
 
 Observed Standard/Criteria
Possible
Points
Rating
  Advertisement is on one page of poster paper.  20  
  Advertisement is engaging – causes the viewer to look with interest, pause, and read.   20  
  Advertisement is informative – provides viewer with important/relevant information.  20  
  Advertisement includes a recommendation for a BEST VALUE piece of equipment in each category.   40  
       
 
TOTALS
 100  

Comments: